Irresistible Dairy-Free Peanut Butter and Jam Cookies (PB&J Cookie Cups Recipe)

Craving a delightful sweet treat that’s both satisfying and good for you? Look no further than these incredible Peanut Butter and Jam Cookies! Imagine tiny, dairy-free cookie cups, each with a wonderfully chewy peanut butter base, perfectly cradling a vibrant, refined sugar-free chia jam filling. This small-batch recipe is designed for those moments when you desire a healthier indulgence without overdoing it – making them the ideal afternoon snack or a lighter dessert option.

This beloved recipe was first introduced in March 2017. It has since been meticulously updated to bring you fresh photos, enhanced text, and invaluable tips to ensure your baking success. We’ve also made a few thoughtful adjustments to the recipe itself to perfect its taste and texture. (For a fun comparison, you can find an original photo at the very end of this post to see the amazing transformation!)

I confess, I’m one of those people who absolutely thrives on a little something sweet in the middle of the afternoon. It’s never anything overly rich or heavy, just a small, comforting bite that hits that sweet spot and pairs beautifully with a warm cup of tea. It’s a ritual that brings a moment of calm to my busy day.

For this reason, you’ll almost always find a secret stash of these mini peanut butter and jam cookies tucked away in my fridge or freezer. They’re deliberately portion-controlled and not excessively sweet, yet they are incredibly filling. Thanks to the wholesome ingredients, they also pack a little extra fiber and protein, transforming them into a genuinely healthier snack that you can feel good about enjoying. They satisfy without the guilt, making them a perfect pick-me-up.

Why You’ll Fall in Love with These Dairy-Free PB&J Cookie Cups

These healthier PB&J cookie cups aren’t just delicious; they offer a multitude of reasons to become your new favorite treat:

• Dairy-Free Delight: Perfect for those with dairy sensitivities or following a vegan diet (if using an egg substitute like a flax egg, which can work well).
• Refined Sugar-Free Jam: The homemade chia jam is naturally sweetened, allowing the fresh fruit flavors to shine without excessive added sugars.
• Wholesome Ingredients: Made with natural peanut butter, coconut oil, and whole wheat flour, offering a more nutritious alternative to traditional cookies.
• Chewy & Satisfying Texture: The peanut butter cookie base is wonderfully soft and chewy, complementing the luscious jam filling.
• Small Batch Recipe: Yields 12 perfect mini cookies, ideal for preventing overindulgence and ensuring fresh treats without a huge commitment. Easily doubled if you need more!
• Easy to Make: With straightforward steps, even novice bakers can confidently whip up a batch of these delightful cookie cups.
• Freezer-Friendly: A great recipe for meal prepping snacks – simply freeze and thaw for a quick treat anytime.

Delving Deeper into Key Ingredients for Your Peanut Butter and Jam Cookies

Understanding the role of each ingredient is crucial for achieving the perfect texture and flavor in your PB&J cookie cups. Let’s break down a few of the stars of this recipe:

Peanut Butter Perfection

For these chewy peanut butter cookies, I exclusively use natural smooth peanut butter. The reason is simple: its smooth, consistent texture lends itself beautifully to baking these delicate cookie cups, ensuring a uniform and tender crumb. While I haven’t personally experimented with crunchy peanut butter for this specific recipe, it would likely work, albeit giving your cookies a noticeably more textural, nutty bite. A word of caution: I strongly advise against using “regular” or conventional peanut butter (the kind that often contains added sugars, hydrogenated oils, and stabilizers). These types tend to be much oilier and can result in cookie cups that are too greasy and don’t hold their shape as well, fundamentally altering the intended outcome of this healthier recipe.

The Magic of Chia Jam

The star of the filling in these Peanut Butter and Jam Cookies is a homemade chia jam, typically made with a delightful medley of strawberries, blackberries, and blueberries. However, the beauty of this recipe lies in its flexibility! Feel free to unleash your creativity and use any fresh or frozen berries you have readily available. Raspberries and cherries, for instance, make wonderful additions, infusing the jam with their unique tartness and sweetness. I’ve even had great success making these cookies with a vibrant blueberry pomegranate chia jam, which adds a lovely burst of flavor. Chia seeds not only help thicken the jam naturally but also provide a welcome boost of fiber and omega-3 fatty acids, making your sweet treat even healthier.

Coconut Oil Choice

In this recipe, virgin, cold-pressed coconut oil is my preferred choice. Its semi-solid state at room temperature effectively mimics the consistency of softened butter, which is essential for achieving the correct dough texture. I’ve specifically avoided testing this recipe with liquid (fractionated) coconut oil. My assumption is that liquid coconut oil would likely make the cookie dough far too soft and greasy, potentially causing the cookie cups to spread excessively or become oily during baking. Using the right type of coconut oil ensures the dough maintains its structure and results in perfectly formed, chewy cookie cups.

Step-by-Step Guide: Crafting Your Own PB&J Cookie Cups in a Mini Muffin Pan

First, Prepare the Chia Jam Filling

The delicious chia jam filling is incredibly simple to prepare, requiring minimal effort for maximum flavor.

• Begin by combining your chosen berries (fresh or frozen) and a touch of maple syrup in a small saucepan. Bring this mixture to a gentle boil over medium heat.
• Once boiling, reduce the heat to a simmer and let it cook for approximately 10 minutes. This allows the berries to soften beautifully and release their juices, creating a rich base for your jam.
• Remove the saucepan from the heat. Using a fork or a potato masher, gently mash the softened berries to your desired consistency – some prefer a chunkier jam, while others like it smoother.
• Stir in the chia seeds thoroughly. The chia seeds will work their magic as the jam cools, absorbing moisture and thickening to that perfect spoonable consistency. Allow the jam to rest until it has sufficiently thickened, which usually takes about 15-20 minutes.
• Quick Tip: If you’re short on time or prefer a different flavor, you can certainly opt for your favorite homemade or high-quality store-bought jam as an alternative filling. Just be mindful of added sugars in pre-made jams.

Next, Prepare the Chewy Cookie Cups

Now for the heart of our Peanut Butter and Jam Cookies – the delightful peanut butter base!

• Step 1: Cream the Wet Ingredients. In a mixing bowl, use an electric mixer to thoroughly beat together the natural peanut butter, virgin coconut oil, and coconut sugar until the mixture becomes wonderfully creamy and light. This step is crucial for incorporating air and ensuring a tender cookie.
• Step 2: Add Egg & Vanilla. Incorporate the large egg and vanilla extract into the creamy mixture. Continue to beat until everything is smooth and well combined. Don’t forget to scrape down the sides of your mixing bowl occasionally to ensure all ingredients are fully integrated.
• Step 3: Whisk Dry Ingredients. In a separate bowl, whisk together the whole wheat flour, kosher salt, baking powder, and baking soda. This ensures an even distribution of leavening agents throughout the dough.
• Step 4: Combine Wet and Dry. Gradually add the whisked dry ingredients into the wet mixture, beating on low speed until a cohesive dough forms. Avoid overmixing, as this can lead to tough cookies.
• Step 5: Fill the Muffin Pan. Lightly grease a 12-cavity mini muffin pan with non-stick cooking spray. Using a 1 1/2-inch cookie scoop (or a tablespoon), place mounds of the dough evenly into each cavity.
• Step 6: Form the Cups. This is where the “cup” in cookie cup comes in! Gently press your thumb into the middle of each dough mound to create a well. Then, carefully shape the dough around the sides of the cavities, forming neat little cups ready for their delicious filling.

• Steps 7 & 8: Initial Bake & Re-shape. Bake the cookie cups in your preheated oven for just 5 minutes. Upon removing them, you’ll notice the cups will have puffed up slightly. This is normal! Using the back of a small teaspoon, carefully press down into the middle of each cup to re-create a defined well, preparing it for the jam.
• Step 9: Fill & Final Bake. Now, spoon your homemade chia jam (or preferred jam) into each cookie cup, filling them generously. Return the pan to the oven and bake for an additional 7-8 minutes, or until the edges of the cookies are lightly golden brown.
• Step 10: Cool & Release. Allow the cookies to cool completely in the muffin pan for at least 15 minutes. This cooling period is crucial as it helps the cookies firm up and makes them much easier to remove without breaking. Once cooled, use a small knife or offset spatula to gently lift them out of the pan. Transfer them to a wire rack to cool completely.

Frequently Asked Questions About These PB&J Cookies

Got questions about these delightful Peanut Butter and Jam Cookies? We’ve got answers to help you perfect every batch!

Can you use another type of jam? Absolutely! While I’m a big proponent of using chia jam for its added fiber and protein benefits (and refined sugar-free goodness), if chia jam isn’t quite your ‘jam’, feel free to use your favorite homemade or store-bought variety as the filling. Just be mindful that most commercial jams will likely contain added refined sugars, which might change the “healthier” aspect slightly.

What’s the difference between jam and jelly, and why ‘jam’ cookies? That’s a great question, and it’s why I specifically call these ‘Peanut Butter and Jam Cookies’ rather than ‘jelly cookies’. In this recipe, I’m using a pure, fruit-filled jam that often contains small chunks of fruit and has a spoonable, slightly rustic texture, which is ideal for filling the cookie cups. Jelly, on the other hand, is made primarily from the filtered juice of cooked fruit, resulting in a clear, gel-like consistency without any fruit pulp. I haven’t tested this recipe with jellies, and their consistency might not hold up as well or provide the same rich texture within the cookie cup.

Can you use another type of nut butter to make these cookies? Yes, you certainly can! If you have an allergy to peanuts, or simply prefer a different flavor, you can substitute natural smooth almond butter or even cashew butter. I’ve personally made these cookies with natural almond butter, and they turned out beautifully with a slightly different, yet equally delicious, flavor profile. Ensure it’s a natural, unsweetened variety for the best results.

How do you store these PB&J cookies to keep them fresh? Due to their fresh chia jam filling, these cookies are best stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator. This helps maintain the freshness of the jam and keeps the cookie base perfectly chewy.

How long will these delicious cookie cups last? When stored properly in an airtight container in the refrigerator, they should remain fresh and delightful for 5-7 days. They make excellent grab-and-go snacks throughout the week!

Can you freeze these Peanut Butter and Jam Cookies? Yes, they are wonderfully freezer-friendly! Once the cookies have completely cooled on a wire rack, arrange them in a single layer in a freezer-safe container, or place parchment paper between layers. They can be frozen for up to 3 months. To enjoy, simply defrost them in the refrigerator overnight or for a few hours at room temperature before serving.

Additional Recipe Tips and Smart Substitutions for Success

Beyond the main instructions, these tips will help you achieve the best possible dairy-free peanut butter and jam cookies every time:

• Berry Varieties for Chia Jam: While strawberries, blackberries, and blueberries are a classic trio for the chia jam filling, don’t limit yourself! Feel free to use any seasonal fresh or frozen berries you have on hand. Mixed berries often create the most complex and delicious flavor.
• Salted vs. Unsalted Peanut Butter: I typically use natural salted peanut butter in this recipe, as the hint of salt perfectly balances the sweetness. If you only have unsalted natural peanut butter, you might want to add an extra pinch (about 1/8 to 1/4 teaspoon) of kosher salt to your cookie dough mixture to achieve that ideal flavor balance.
• Room Temperature Ingredients are Key: When baking with virgin, cold-pressed coconut oil, it’s particularly important to ensure that all your cold ingredients (like the egg) are brought to room temperature before mixing. This simple step helps prevent the coconut oil from solidifying prematurely during the mixing process, ensuring a smooth, uniform dough.
• Patience with Cooling: Resist the urge to remove the cookies from the muffin pan too soon! Allowing the cookies to cool completely in the pan for at least 15 minutes is a critical step. This cooling time helps them firm up and set, making them much easier to lift out without breaking apart.
• Scaling the Recipe: This recipe is intentionally a small batch, yielding 12 mini cookie cups – perfect for a quick treat or a small household. If you need more than 12 cookies for a gathering or simply want a larger supply, you can easily double the recipe without any adjustments to the baking time or method.

More Delicious Peanut Butter Treats You Might Enjoy

If you’re a fan of peanut butter, here are some other fantastic recipes from our kitchen that you’re sure to love:

• Peanut Butter Banana Protein Donuts (baked, dairy-free, and gluten-free for a healthier breakfast or snack!)
• Crispy Peanut Butter Balls (these vegan and gluten-free treats are made without any powdered sugar!)
• Chocolate Peanut Butter Nice Cream Cake (a delightful vegan, no-bake cake that only requires 7 simple ingredients!)

If you take the plunge and make these healthier PB&J cookie cups, I would absolutely love to hear your thoughts and experiences! Please share your feedback in the comments section below – your insights are always appreciated!

HUNGRY FOR MORE? Don’t forget to sign up for the Crumb Top Baking Newsletter and follow along on Instagram, Pinterest and Facebook!