The Ultimate Holiday Cookie Box: Decadent, Dietary-Friendly Christmas Treats for Everyone
The holiday season ushers in a cherished tradition of baking and sharing, and nothing embodies the festive spirit quite as beautifully as a thoughtfully curated Holiday Cookie Box. Today, I’m absolutely thrilled to unveil my very first collection of Christmas treats – a delightful assortment designed to cater to every taste and dietary preference. This carefully assembled box truly boasts something for everyone: from rich, deeply decadent indulgences to wholesome, clean-eating options, and a wonderful selection of dairy-free, grain-free, and even vegan treats!
As this marks my final post before Christmas, I want to take a heartfelt moment to extend my warmest wishes for a truly joyful and peaceful holiday season to each and every one of you. Your consistent visits and unwavering support for Crumb Top Baking throughout 2019 have meant the world to me. I deeply value the connections we’ve forged here and across social media, and I’m eagerly anticipating sharing many more delicious recipes, baking tips, and culinary adventures with you in 2020. Wishing you and your beloved families all the very best!
For many years, baking an abundance of cookies has been an integral and joyful part of my holiday preparations. I vividly remember kicking off my cookie baking marathon as early as November, with the ambitious goal of creating 15 to 20 different varieties. These delicious creations would then be meticulously stashed away in the freezer, patiently awaiting their grand unveiling during the festive season. While I’ve certainly scaled back the sheer number of types in more recent years, the cherished tradition of offering a wide, enticing variety remains strong. I still find immense joy in baking around 8 to 10 distinct kinds, ensuring there’s plenty of assortment to generously fill the Christmas cookie tins that I lovingly gift to friends, family, and neighbors.
This year, for a brief moment, a flicker of doubt crossed my mind about whether I would be able to uphold the tradition of gifting homemade cookies. Despite dedicating a considerable amount of time to baking new recipes for the blog, personal holiday baking for others had, until recently, taken a backseat. However, this past weekend, I happily managed to carve out some dedicated time for a glorious holiday baking frenzy. The delightful result? Seven distinct, utterly delicious, and perfectly festive kinds of cookies, baked with an extra dash of love and now ready to be shared with you – both in person and virtually! Each cookie in this box tells a story of holiday cheer and culinary passion.
Why Create a Holiday Cookie Box? The Art of Gifting and Sharing
A holiday cookie box transcends being merely a collection of sweets; it’s a heartfelt gesture of love, a beautiful showcase of culinary creativity, and a truly delightful way to share the festive spirit. Its primary appeal lies in offering incredible variety, guaranteeing that every recipient or guest finds a treat perfectly suited to their palate. From crunchy textures to delightfully chewy centers, from warm, spicy notes to rich, chocolatey depths, and crucially, incorporating options that cater to specific dietary needs, a cookie box truly celebrates the diversity of holiday tastes. Beyond its delicious contents, it also serves as a stunning centerpiece for any holiday gathering and makes for an unforgettable, deeply personalized gift that speaks volumes of thoughtfulness.
What’s Inside My Curated 2019 Holiday Cookie Box: A Symphony of Flavors
Narrowing down my favorite recipes for this special holiday collection was a deliciously difficult task, but these seven cookies represent some of our most beloved and frequently requested creations. More importantly, they were chosen for their exceptional suitability for gifting, their ability to travel well (for hand-delivery, at least!), and their universal crowd-pleasing appeal for festive gatherings and holiday cookie exchanges. Here’s a closer look at the delightful assortment, crafted to bring joy to every bite:
- Chewy Ginger Cookies with Lemon Cream Cheese Frosting
- Crispy Peanut Butter Balls (Vegan & Gluten-Free)
- Cranberry Chocolate Chip Cookie Bars (Grain-Free & Dairy-Free)
- Cranberry Orange Thumbprint Cookies
- Double Chocolate Peppermint Cookies
- Cookie Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies
- Chocolate Chai Spice Crumble Bars (Gluten-Free & Vegan)
Important Considerations for Your Holiday Cookie Box: Gifting and Presentation Tips
When preparing your own holiday cookie box, a few practical tips can elevate your gifting experience:
- Presentation Matters: While I’m showcasing these cookies beautifully arranged in an open box for photographic purposes, for actual gifting, I strongly recommend packaging them securely in festive Christmas tins, decorative cardboard boxes, or other sealable containers. This not only keeps the cookies fresh but also prevents them from shifting or getting damaged during transport. An open box display, however, is absolutely perfect for serving at your own holiday dinner table, a potluck, or a casual gathering, allowing guests to admire the variety before choosing their favorite. Consider adding parchment paper or festive cupcake liners between layers for extra protection and visual appeal.
- Hand-Delivery is Key: It’s crucial to remember that some of these delectable cookies, particularly those featuring delicate cream cheese frosting or certain moist fillings, require refrigeration to maintain their freshness and structural integrity. Therefore, this particular collection is not suitable for shipping long distances in the mail. These precious treats are best packaged with care and hand-delivered to your lucky recipients, ensuring they arrive perfectly fresh, delicious, and exactly as intended. If you plan to ship, opt for sturdier, non-refrigerated cookie varieties.
Chewy Ginger Cookies with Lemon Cream Cheese Frosting: A Zesty Holiday Favorite
These incredible Chewy Ginger Cookies first made their eagerly awaited appearance on the blog last year as part of my enthusiastic review of Oh Sweet Day! A Celebration Cookbook. Since then, they have quite literally skyrocketed in popularity, becoming one of the most beloved and frequently visited cookie recipes on the entire site! These delightful sandwich cookies boast an irresistibly chewy texture, generously spiced with the warm, comforting notes of ginger. This robust and cozy base is then exquisitely complemented by a slightly tart yet wonderfully sweet lemon cream cheese filling, creating a harmonious balance of flavors that makes them truly exceptional and utterly perfect for the festive holiday season. They’re a crowd-pleaser that embodies both classic comfort and bright, fresh appeal.
Crispy Peanut Butter Balls: A Healthier, Vegan Holiday Indulgence
Peanut butter balls are an undeniable holiday classic, a cherished treat that always makes a welcome appearance during the festive season. For this year’s cookie box, I was keen to put a healthier, yet equally satisfying and utterly delicious, spin on this typically decadent confection. My unique version is thoughtfully crafted without any powdered sugar or traditional butter, instead relying on the natural, golden sweetness of pure maple syrup. Each bite of these treats is densely packed with rich natural peanut butter, the delightful crunch of raw peanuts and walnuts, and the light, crispy texture of brown rice cereal. As an added bonus for various dietary considerations, these Crispy Peanut Butter Balls are naturally gluten-free, and I’ve made further, careful adjustments to the recipe this year to ensure they are completely vegan, making them a wonderfully inclusive and guilt-free pleasure for even more people to enjoy!
Cranberry Chocolate Chip Cookie Bars: Grain-Free and Dairy-Free Festive Delights
There’s an undeniable magic and harmony in the vibrant combination of tart cranberries, bright, sweet orange zest, and rich dark chocolate, especially when these flavors converge during the joyous festive season. If you wholeheartedly agree with this sentiment, then you are absolutely going to adore these Cranberry Chocolate Chip Cookie Bars. These delightful bars are generously loaded with plump, juicy fresh cranberries, aromatic orange zest that perfumes every bite, and an abundance of luscious dark chocolate chips. What makes them even more remarkably special is their thoughtful and health-conscious ingredient list: they’re lovingly made with wholesome almond flour, creamy almond butter, and nourishing coconut oil, making them a fantastic grain-free and dairy-free option that doesn’t compromise one bit on exceptional flavor or festive appeal. They are soft, wonderfully chewy, and burst with undeniable holiday cheer in every single square.
Cranberry Orange Thumbprint Cookies: A Classic with a Zesty Twist
These exquisite Cranberry Orange Thumbprint Cookies are yet another magnificent example of the beloved cranberry, orange, and chocolate trifecta that consistently finds its way into my regular holiday baking rotation. Each cookie offers a truly delightful textural contrast – starting with perfectly crispy edges that gently give way to a wonderfully chewy interior, all encased in a delicate, sparkling sugary exterior. The true highlight, however, is the intensely flavorful and vibrant orange cranberry chia seed filling, lovingly nestled in the signature thumbprint in the center of each cookie. While the photo here beautifully showcases their natural, unfettered charm, I wholeheartedly recommend finishing them off with a generous, elegant drizzle of melted white or dark chocolate. Trust me when I say that this simple chocolate drizzle elevates them from merely delicious to absolutely irresistible, adding an extra layer of festive decadence!
Double Chocolate Peppermint Cookies: The Iconic Duo of Christmas
Is there truly a more iconic, festive flavor pairing for the holidays than the dynamic duo of rich chocolate and refreshing peppermint? These Double Chocolate Peppermint Cookies are, without a doubt, an absolute must-try to truly capture the exhilarating essence of Christmas in every single bite! These cookies are wonderfully soft and perfectly chewy, boasting a luxurious cocoa-rich base generously studded with substantial chunks of premium dark chocolate. A bright, invigorating hint of peppermint extract expertly weaves its way through every mouthful, beautifully complemented by the delightful crunch of vibrant crushed candy canes sprinkled generously on top. You’ll definitely want to save at least a few of these extra-special cookies for Santa on Christmas Eve – they pair absolutely perfectly with a tall glass of cold milk or a warm, comforting cup of hot cocoa, ensuring his busy delivery route is just a little bit sweeter!
Cookie Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies: A Spiced Twist on a Classic
While classic chocolate chip cookies might not be the very first thing that springs to mind when you envision a holiday cookie box, adding the irresistible magic of cookie butter truly transforms them into something incredibly special and perfectly spiced for the season. For those perhaps unfamiliar, cookie butter is a delightful, creamy spread made from finely crushed Biscoff biscuits – those wonderfully crispy spice cookies that are so immensely popular across Europe, especially cherished during the holidays. Infusing these soft-batch chocolate chip cookies with cookie butter imparts a subtle yet distinctly warm hint of cinnamon and ginger, beautifully balanced with the fragrant nuttiness of toasted coconut and generous, melting dark chocolate chips. For an extra indulgent, gloriously ooey-gooey experience, a quick warm-up in the microwave is highly, highly recommended. These Cookie Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies are a unique, memorable, and utterly addictive addition to any festive spread.
Chocolate Chai Spice Crumble Bars: Irresistible Gluten-Free & Vegan Comfort
Chai spice desserts have been my absolute weakness and a delightful obsession this entire holiday season, and for incredibly good reason! I’ve honestly lost count of how many times I’ve baked my beloved Chai Spice Cake, and these Chocolate Chai Spice Crumble Bars unquestionably rank high on my list of seasonal favorites too. I initially introduced these comforting bars two years ago, and since then, I’ve made thoughtful and precise adjustments to the recipe to ensure they are both completely gluten-free and delightfully vegan, making them wonderfully accessible and enjoyable for even more people. They feature a delightful, rustic crumble base made with wholesome oats and coconut, generously infused with the rich, warming, and aromatic flavors of classic chai spices. Beneath this fragrant, textural crumble lies a thick, profoundly rich, and fudgy chocolate filling that is simply, utterly irresistible. These bars offer the perfect combination of comforting spices and decadent chocolate, a truly outstanding and nourishing treat for any holiday gathering or a cozy night in.
I genuinely hope you’re inspired to try some of these wonderful recipes from my 2019 Holiday Cookie Box! Whether you’re baking for loved ones or simply treating yourself, these delicious creations are sure to bring joy. If you do make any of these delightful treats, I would absolutely love to hear your thoughts, experiences, and any delicious modifications you make in the comments section below. Your feedback truly brightens my day and helps foster our baking community!
HUNGRY FOR MORE? Don’t forget to sign up for the Crumb Top Baking Newsletter to receive new recipes and baking inspiration directly in your inbox! You can also follow along with our daily baking adventures and connect with us on Instagram, find delicious ideas on Pinterest and stay updated on our latest posts on Facebook!
Happy Holidays and Happy Baking to all!